Summer 2019 eNewsletter
Featured Research
Modeling Lake Michigan’s Suitability for Bigheaded Carps
The invasion of several notorious non-native species, such as the sea lamprey and zebra mussels, have transformed the ecological landscape of the Great Lakes. As efforts to understand and minimize the damage of already entrenched invaders continue, the prevention of new invasions has become the strategic priority of invasive species management and has motivated research that identifies which species pose the greatest threat to the Great Lakes. Of the many species being monitored by scientists, perhaps none are more concerning than bighead and silver carp (collectively referred to as bigheaded carp).
Bigheaded carp are the two plankton-feeding species of Asian carp that were imported to the United States in the 1970s as a means of controlling algal growth in reservoirs and sewage treatment lagoons. These species escaped into natural waterways, quickly spreading throughout the Mississippi River basin. Bigheaded carp have established dense populations in many rivers, including the Illinois River where they comprise 63% of the total fish biomass. Bigheaded carp disrupt aquatic food webs by voraciously feeding on zooplankton and phytoplankton, limiting the food available to resident plankton-feeding fishes and potentially impacting the larger predatory fish that feed upon them. While they prefer to eat plankton, bigheaded carp will consume alternative foods, such as detritus and bacteria, when plankton becomes less available.
The close proximity of the bigheaded carp population to Lake Michigan has elevated concerns about the impact they could have on the Great Lakes food web, which supports a $7 billion recreational fishery. While their insatiable appetites, flexible diets, rapid growth, and reproduction rates make bigheaded carp a formidable invader, Lake Michigan is colder and has less plankton than the environments where they currently exist. Reductions in nutrient loads over the past 50 years and the proliferation of the invasive filter-feeding quagga mussels have transformed Lake Michigan into a plankton desert, which has prompted the question: does Lake Michigan have enough food for Bighead and Silver carp to thrive?
Previous research indicated that bigheaded carp could only survive in plankton-dense areas of Lake Michigan, such as Green Bay, but important knowledge gaps persist. These studies only considered the food available at the water surface, though a deep-water layer of algae is common during summer, and did not evaluate the possibility of bigheaded carp feeding on non-plankton food sources.
To develop a more complete understanding of bigheaded carp invasion risk, Peter Alsip (CIGLR’s Ecological Modeling Data Analyst) and a team of scientists from CIGLR and NOAA GLERL have constructed a model that evaluates the suitability of Lake Michigan habitats for bigheaded carp growth. This approach (referred to as a “growth rate potential model”) measures habitat quality based on water temperature, prey abundance, and bigheaded carps’ physiological requirements for growth. The detailed data produced by the model allowed the team to evaluate habitat quality throughout the entire lake, including subsurface environments, while also accounting for the ability of bigheaded carp to feed on an alternative prey item, detritus, as well as their preferred prey: phytoplankton and zooplankton.
Not surprisingly, the model indicated that habitats with greatest potential to support bigheaded carp were located near river mouths and in the algae-rich area of Green bay, which agrees with previous studies. However, in contrast to previous studies, they also found suitable offshore habitat for Bighead carp (Figure 1) due to the added considerations of diet flexibility and subsurface food sources. While a majority of Lake Michigan’s offshore areas are suitable for Bighead Carp, they are relatively low in quality, which will make it less appealing for the fish to reside there for extended periods. However, the suitability of offshore habitat may provide migration corridors through which bigheaded carp could spread to more food-rich areas in the lake.
Using the same approach described above, Peter is currently conducting research to understand how meteorology, lake-wide phosphorus loads, and invasive mussel filtration affect bigheaded carp habitat suitability. This new study seeks to understand how these stressors individually and interactively influence the vulnerability of Lake Michigan to bigheaded carp.
“Our new study is exciting because it could provide a basis for understanding how a warming climate will affect Lake Michigan’s suitability for bigheaded carp in the future. It will also help explain how past changes in nutrient loads and invasive mussels have shaped habitat suitability as we understand it today,” says Alsip.
Related Resources
- CIGLR Minute: Asian Carp Research (video)
- Invasive Species (webpage)
- Alsip, P.J. 2018. Modeling Lake Michigan’s Suitability for Bigheaded Carps: The Importance of Diet Flexibility and Subsurface Habitat. (thesis)
- Alsip, P.J., H. Zhang, M.D. Rowe, D.M. Mason, E.S. Rutherford, C.M. Riseng and Z. Su. 2019. Lake Michigan’s suitability for bigheaded carp: The importance of diet flexibility and subsurface habitat. Freshwater Biology. DOI:10.1111/fwb.13382. (article)
Related News Articles
- Are the Great Lakes next? Video shows hundreds of Asian carp shocked in Kentucky lake, Fox 2 Detroit, 8/1/2019
- U-M study: Asian carp capable of surviving in much larger areas of Lake Michigan than previously thought, Michigan News, 8/12/2019
- Asian carp have never breached a body of freshwater the size of Lake Michigan. Here’s the bizarre way they could survive and thrive in the world’s fifth largest lake, Chicago Tribune, 8/12/2019
Full List of Related News Articles
- Favorite food not on the menu? No problem for Asian carp – they eat almost anything, Great Lakes Echo, 8/21/2019
- Lake Michigan’s ‘Plankton Desert’ No Problem for Bighead Carp, Peninsula Pulse, 8/16/2019
- A mussel poop diet could fuel invasive carp’s spread across Lake Michigan, Science News, 8/13/2019
- New Study Finds Asian Carp Could Survive Throughout Lake Michigan, Wisconsin Public Radio, 8/12/2019
- Asian carp could be a lot worse to the Great Lakes that previously thought, UofM study shows, Fox 2 Detroit, 8/12/2019
- U-M: Asian carp would have sufficient food supply in Lake Michigan, Holland Sentinel, 8/12/2019
- Asian carp have never breached a body of freshwater the size of Lake Michigan. Here’s the bizarre way they could survive and thrive in the world’s fifth largest lake, Chicago Tribune, 8/12/2019
- U-M study: Asian carp capable of surviving in much larger areas of Lake Michigan than previously thought, Michigan News, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian Carp could expand across greater area of Lake Michigan than previously thought, Michigan Radio, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could thrive in Lake Michigan, despite earlier doubts, Bridge, 8/12/2019
- Are the Great Lakes next? Video shows hundreds of Asian carp shocked in Kentucky lake, Fox 2 Detroit, 8/1/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, Associated Press, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, ABC News, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, Binghamton Homepage, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, yahoo.com, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, Centre Daily Times, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, WTEN ABC, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, 8 News Now, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, CBS 42, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, WTTW, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, mypanhandle.com, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, AccessWDUN, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, KTAR News 92.3 FM, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, dailyreporter.com, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, Travel Breaking News, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, Wisconsin State Journal, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, 62 CBS Detroit, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, KXNet.com, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, LocalSYR.com, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, KHON 2, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, My Twin Tiers, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, WWLP 22 News, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, CEN LA Now, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, Four States Homepage, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, Your Basin, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, News 8 WTNH, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, Belleville News-Democrat, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, News Channel 11 WJHL, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, CBS 13 WOWK TV, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, CIProud.com, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, ABC 27 News, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, CBS 10 KLFY.com , 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, WTRF.com, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, WNCT 9 , 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, The World News, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, FOX16.com, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, WIPROUD.com, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, Fox 21 News, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, CBS 17, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, Count On News 2, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, LMT online, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, UPMatters.com, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, WDHN ABC DoThanFirst.com, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, The Ridgefield Press, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, The Darien Times, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, ICFlorida.com, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, The Trumbull Times, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, CBS Koin 6, Portland, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, KTVN 2 News, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, The Telegraph, Alton, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, FireFighterNation.com, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, My Plainview, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, Boston 25 News, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, ABC 4 Utah, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, 21 WFMJ, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, FOX 23 News, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, WRAL.com, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, Chron, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, The Intelligencer, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, Huron Daily Tribune, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, KXAN, 8/12/2019
- Study: Asian carp could find plenty of food in Lake Michigan, WSB-TV 2, 8/12/2019